Please download to get full document.

View again

of 4
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Information Report



Views: 19 | Pages: 4

Extension: DOCX | Download: 0

Related documents
  Republic of the Philippines SUPREME COURT ManilaEN BANC A.M. No. 08-5-305-RTC July 9, 2013RE: FAILURE OF FORMER JU!E ANTONIO A. CAR ONELL TO ECIE CASES SU MITTEFOR ECISION AN TO RESOL#E PENIN! MOTIONS IN T$E RE!IONAL TRIAL COURT, RANC$ 2%, SAN FERNANO, LA UNION. R E S O L U T I O N ERSAMIN, J.: This administati!e case oi inates fom the #udicial audit conducted b$ the Office of the Cout  Administato %OCA& on Mach ' and () *++, in the Re ional Tial Cout of San -enando) La Union) Banch *.) in !ie/ of the disabilit$ etiement of Pesidin 0ud e Antonio A1 Cabonell on 2ecembe '3) *++.1 Accodin to the Audit Team4s Repot) Banch *. had a total caseload of *'3 cases) consistin of 3(. ciminal cases and ,( ci!il cases) and 0ud e Cabonell failed to decide (3 ciminal cases %one inheited& and ** ci!il cases %fou inheited&) namel$5 Ciminal Case Nos1 33,') (667) 633.) '6'*) '8.*) 6386) 6++.) 67(8) 87'() 6.8') .+3() 6773) (.*() 8'33) 8+.8) (.,7) 8*7.) 6(*() (7*,) 8(+') 8,38) 68'6) 6888) 63'() 6,86) 8*,() 8(6() 6'7() 8..+) 6'.6) 6'68) .66.) 67(+) 8'33) 8''') ..*7) .333) 8'*6) 8+8,) 863.) and ..889 and Ci!il Case Nos1 '++7) (68() (68') (.3() '8(.) ('8*) 8+(3) (.7,) (683) 87,7) *,,*) 83,6) .36') .38') LRC *''*) SCA .37,) .'3+) '(,.) .'*.) .''3) .*7,) and .'*'1 3 0ud e Cabonell /as also epoted to ha!e failed to esol!e pendin motions o incidents in fou ciminal cases and 3* ci!il cases) to /it5 Ciminal Case Nos1 .667) 8(+7) ..,.) and ..,,9 and Ci!il Case Nos1 (.7') LRC 3'+,) .+8() (7.') SP *7+3) SP *76*) AC 3.7.) .3++) .36*) .+8+) SP *7,8) and SP *7,.1 * In a Memoandum dated Ma$ 36) *++,) the OCA ecommended to the Cout that a fine of P6+)+++1++ be imposed upon 0ud e Cabonell fo oss inefficienc$ fo failin to pomptl$ decide the cases and to esol!e pendin motions and incidents1 ' On 0une 3.) *++,) the Cout diected the Cle: of Cout to funish 0ud e Cabonell /ith a cop$ of the Audit Team4s Repot) and odeed him to submit his comment on the epot /ithin ten da$s fom notice1 ( Not ha!in ecei!ed the comment fom 0ud e Cabonell despite the lapse of the time i!en) the Cout esol!ed on Septembe *3) *+3+ to e;uie him to sho/ cause /h$ he should not be disciplinail$ dealt /ith o held in contempt1 6 0ud e Cabonell eplied) 8  statin that he had incopoated his comment<compliance to the 0une 3.) *++, esolution in the lette dated 0ul$ 3.) *++, %Re5 =e$ U ent Re;uest fo Release of 2isabilit$  Retiement Benefits and Mone$ =alue of Accued Lea!e Cedits& he had sent to Chief 0ustice Re$nato S1 Puno1 .  >e ema:ed that the Cout had actuall$ anted his e;uest fo the pa$ment of his disabilit$ etiement benefits sub#ect to the etention of P*++)+++1++ pendin esolution of the pendin administati!e cases a ainst him1 , In his 0ul$ 3.) *++, lette to Chief 0ustice Puno) 0ud e Cabonell sumised that the Audit Team mi ht ha!e o!eloo:ed the fact that he had inheited some of the undecided cases fom the pedecesso #ud e9 that said cases had no tanscipts of steno aphic notes) because of /hich he /as impelled to e;uie the paties to submit thei especti!e memoanda9 that the cases /ould onl$ be consideed submitted fo decision afte the paties /ould ha!e filed thei especti!e memoanda9 and that he had unde one a ;uaduple heat b$pass opeation in *++6 that had ad!esel$ affected his pace in decidin the cases1On No!embe *') *+3+) the Cout efeed 0ud e Cabonell4s lette to the OCA fo e!aluation) epot)and ecommendation1 7 In its Memoandum dated -ebua$ *) *+33) 3+  the OCA eiteated its ecommendation to impose a fine of P6+)+++1++ on 0ud e Cabonell) notin that he had failed to ende an$ !alid eason fo his dela$ in decidin the cases submitted fo decision and in esol!in the pendin motions o incidents in othe cases1 The OCA noted that onl$ fi!e cases submitted fo decision had been inheited9 and that the case ecods did not bea an$ e;uests fo e?tension of time o an$ diecti!e fo the tansciption of steno aphic notes1 It stessed that hea!$ caseload /ould not #ustif$ the failue to pomptl$ decide and esol!e cases because he could ha!e simpl$ as:ed the Cout fo an e?tension of time1The ecommendation of the OCA is /ell@ta:en) sub#ect to the modification of the penalt$ to be imposed1 As a fontline official of the 0udicia$) a tial #ud e should at all times act /ith efficienc$ and pobit$1 >e is dut$@bound not onl$ to be faithful to the la/) but also to maintain pofessional competence1 Thepusuit of e?cellence ou ht al/a$s to be his uidin pinciple1 Such dedication is the least that he can do to sustain the tust and confidence that the public ha!e eposed in him and the institution he epesents1 33 The Cout cannot o!estess its polic$ on pompt disposition o esolution of cases1 3*  2ela$ in the disposition of cases is a ma#o culpit in the eosion of public faith and confidence in the #udicial s$stem) as #ud es ha!e the s/on dut$ to administe #ustice /ithout undue dela$1 3'  Thus) #ud es ha!e been constantl$ eminded to stictl$ adhee to the ule on the speed$ disposition of cases and obse!e the peiods pescibed b$ the Constitution fo decidin cases) /hich is thee months fom the filin of the last pleadin ) bief o memoandum fo lo/e couts1 3( To futhe impess upon #ud es such mandate) the Cout has issued uidelines %Administati!e Cicula No1 '@77 dated 0anua$ 36) 3777& that /ould insue the speed$ disposition of cases and has theein eminded #ud es to scupulousl$ obse!e the peiods pescibed in the Constitution1Nonetheless) the Cout has been mindful of the pli ht of ou #ud es and undestandin of cicumstances that ma$ hinde them fom pomptl$ disposin of thei businesses1 >ence) the Cout has allo/ed e?tensions of time to decide cases be$ond the 7+@da$ peiod1 All that a #ud e needs to do is to e;uest and #ustif$ an e?tension of time to decide the cases) and the Cout has almost in!aiabl$ anted such e;uest1  0ud e Cabonell failed to decide a total of 8' cases and to esol!e 38 pendin motions o incidents /ithin the 7+@da$ e lementa$ peiod1 >e intimated that his poo health affected his pace in decidin the cases1 >ad such been the case) then he should ha!e e?plained his pedicament to the Cout and as:ed fo an e?tension of time to decide the cases1 Unfotunatel$) he failed to do so10ud e Cabonell claims that some of the inheited cases had no tanscipts of steno aphic notes) theeb$ pe!entin him fom esol!in the cases on time1 >e posits that a case /ould not be consideed submitted fo decision if the paties did not $et file thei especti!e memoanda1 1âwphi1 The Audit Team4s Repot sho/s that) in an appaent attempt to suspend the unnin of the 7+@da$ peiod to decide the cases) 0ud e Cabonell libeall$ a!e the paties in most of the o!edue cases se!eal e?tensions of time to file thei especti!e memoanda1 Some e?tensions /ee e!en fo indefinite peiods) /ith the paties bein simpl$ i!en ample time to file thei memo) as the ele!antcout odes stated1In !ie/ of the foe oin ) 0ud e Cabonell4s e?cuses ae futile in the li ht of the follo/in po!isions of Administati!e Cicula No1 *,) dated 0ul$ ') 37,7) !i5%'& A case is consideed submitted fo decision upon the admission of the e!idence of the paties at the temination of the tial1 The ninet$ %7+& da$s peiod fo decidin the case shall commence to un fomsubmission of the case fo decision /ithout memoanda9 in case the Cout e;uies o allo/s its filin ) the case shall be consideed submitted fo decision upon the filin of the last memoandum o the e?piation of the peiod to do so) /hiche!e is ealie1 Lac: of tanscipt of steno aphic notes shall not be a !alid eason to inteupt o suspend the peiod fo decidin the case unless the case /as pe!iousl$ head b$ anothe #ud e not the decidin #ud e in /hich case the latte shall ha!e the full peiod of ninet$ %7+& da$s fom the completion of the tanscipts /ithin /hich to decide the same1%(&The cout ma$ ant e?tension of time to file memoanda) but the ninet$ %7+& da$ peiod fo decidin shall not be inteupted theeb$1ithout a doubt) 0ud e Cabonell4s failue to decide se!eal cases /ithin the e lementa$ peiod) /ithout #ustifiable and cedible easons) constituted oss inefficienc$) /aantin the imposition of administati!e sanctions) 36  li:e fines1 The fines imposed ha!e !aied in each case) dependin chiefl$ on the numbe of cases not decided /ithin the e lementa$ peiod and othe factos) includin the pesence of a a!atin o miti atin cicumstances li:e the dama e suffeed b$ the paties fom the dela$) the health condition and a e of the #ud e) etc1 38  Thus) in one case) the Cout miti ated the liabilit$ of a 0ud e /ho had been suffein fom illnesses and /ho had late etied due to disabilit$) and imposed upon him a fine of P*+)+++1++ fo failue to decide '3 cases1 3. Considein that 0ud e Cabonell similal$ etied due to disabilit$) the Cout belie!es that his poo health condition eatl$ contibuted to his inabilit$ to efficientl$ pefom his duties as a tial #ud e1 That miti ated his administati!e liabilit$) fo /hich eason the Cout educes the ecommended penalt$ of fine fom P6+)+++1++ to P*+)+++1++1  >ERE-ORE) Retied 0ud e Antonio A1 Cabonell is OR2ERE2 to pa$ a fine of P*+)+++1++ to be deducted fom the P*++)+++1++ that /as /ithheld fom his etiement benefits) and the balance to beimmediatel$ eleased to him1SO OR2ERE21
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks