Menopausal Hot Flashes: A Review of Physiology and Biosociocultural Perspective on Methods of Assessment 1,2

Please download to get full document.

View again

of 6
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Information Report
Category:

Film

Published:

Views: 0 | Pages: 6

Extension: PDF | Download: 0

Share
Related documents
Description
The Journal of Nutrition Supplement: Equol, Soy, and Menopause Menopausal Hot Flashes: A Review of Physiology and Biosociocultural Perspective on Methods of Assessment 1,2 Fredi Kronenberg* Clayman Institute
Transcript
The Journal of Nutrition Supplement: Equol, Soy, and Menopause Menopausal Hot Flashes: A Review of Physiology and Biosociocultural Perspective on Methods of Assessment 1,2 Fredi Kronenberg* Clayman Institute for Gender Research, Stanford University, Stanford, CA Abstract Hot flashes continue to be a troublesome problem for menopausal women the world over. After.50 y of research, we still do not understand the etiology and mechanism of hot flashes, nor do we know how estrogen, the major pharmaceutical treatment, works to reduce hot flashes. We are gaining insight into sociocultural complexities that may affect how and whether women report hot flashes. And we are becoming more sophisticated in our research tools (be it questionnaires, physiological monitors, or brain imaging techniques). New aspects of hot flash research, including neuroimaging and the study of genetic polymorphisms, when combined with increasingly nuanced ways of asking questions of culturally distinct populations, provide challenges but rich complexity from which a better understanding will emerge. J. Nutr. 140: 1380S 1385S, Introduction Hot flashes are one of the most common symptoms experienced by women around the world during the transition to and through menopause. Whereas prevalence rates tend to be higher in Western countries than, e.g., in Asian countries, rates vary widely and are likely influenced by a range of factors (1). In the U.S., hot flashes are one of the main reasons women at menopause seek medical help or look for dietary supplements and over-the-counter remedies for relief (2,3). In 2002, after publication of the results from the large NIH-funded Women s Health Initiative study, which indicated that estrogen was harmful on a number of indices, many women stopped taking this hormone therapy (4) and for.30%, bothersome, often severe hot flashes returned (5). These women re-experienced hot 1 Published in a supplement to The Journal of Nutrition. Presented at the Equol, Soy, and Menopause Research Leadership Conference held in Washington, DC, June 16, The supplement coordinator for this supplement is Kara Lewis, Life Sciences Research Organization (LSRO) Senior Staff Scientist. The supplement is the responsibility of the guest editors to whom the Editor of The Journal of Nutrition has delegated supervision of both technical conformity to the published regulations of The Journal of Nutrition and general oversight of the scientific merit of each article. Publication costs for this supplement were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. This publication must therefore be hereby marked advertisement in accordance with 18 USC section 1734 solely to indicate this fact. The Guest Editor for this supplement is Neil Shay. Guest Editor disclosure: Neil Shay declares no conflict of interest. Supplement Coordinator disclosure: Kara Lewis is currently under contract with and receives compensation from the supplement sponsor. She was also compensated for attending and organizing the Equol, Soy, and Menopause Research Leadership Conference and for organizing, writing, editing, or reviewing, and collection of supplemental manuscripts. The opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors and are not attributable to the sponsors or the publisher, Editor, or Editorial Board of The Journal of Nutrition. 2 Author disclosure: F. Kronenberg, no conflicts of interest. * To whom correspondence should be addressed. flashes they thought they had left far behind. Yet, while women have complained of these spells of heat sensation from time immemorial and despite this considerable public health problem, at the start of the 21st century, we still do not understand the etiology or physiology, nor do we know how the most widely used pharmaceutical treatment to date, estrogen, works to relieve hot flashes. This artice aims to provide a brief overview of some aspects of the biology of hot flashes and methods used in research, given insights we now have into biosociocultural factors that influence how we observe and the phenomenon being observed. Emerging areas of research are also discussed. Hot flashes: the phenomenon The terms hot flash and hot flush are used interchangeably and are typically synonymous, referring to a sudden sensation of heat and sweating, most notably on the upper body. Hot flashes occur primarily and most intensively in peri- and postmenopausal women. They also may occur when estrogen drops suddenly and rapidly, such as after removal of the ovaries of premenopausal women, with chemically induced menopause, and also in breast cancer patients treated with selective estrogen receptor modifiers such as tamoxifen. Men can experience hot flashes, particularly when testosterone levels fall rapidly, such as in men with prostate cancer treated medically or surgically. In both women and men, these are situations where there is an abrupt drop in sex steroid hormones, resulting in hot flashes. Hot flashes can occur day or night; when they occur at night, they are called night sweats. Each particular episode lasts between 3 and 10 min and can recur with varying frequency (6). Some women experience hot flashes hourly or daily, while for others they may occur only occasionally; a small percent of women report not having any hot flashes. Whether this is a 1380S ã 2010 American Society for Nutrition. First published online May 26, 2010; doi: /jn matter of a threshold of perception or there are genetic, environmental, or lifestyle factors that preclude hot flashes is a subject of increasing interest. Although for most women, hot flashes begin and have their peak occurrence during the peri- and early postmenopausal periods, typically when a woman is in her late 40s and early 50s, at times they may begin when menstrual cycles are still regular (6). The majority of women have hot flashes for a year or two, but ~15% may have them nonstop for 10, 20, or 30 y (6). And while every woman s estrogen level decreases during the transition to and through menopause, it remains an enigma as to why some women s bodies seem to adjust and hot flashes taper off, while others continue having hot flashes for many years. In addition, for some women whose hot flashes were treated successfully by estrogen, the hot flashes resume after cessation of estrogen treatment. Physiological changes during a hot flash Thermography provides a visual snapshot of the skin surface manifestation of the pattern of thermoregulatory changes during a hot flash and provides insights into underlying physiological changes (Supplemental Fig. 1). One can see the skin areas that warm during the hot flash (fingers, neck, face) and cool as the hot flash subsides. Figure 1 graphically illustrates some of the primary physiological changes that occur during a hot flash (7). Sensation is a subjective rating of the sense of hot flash intensity on a scale of 0 10 (10 being the most intense). At the onset of a hot flash, there is a sudden increase in sweating. Heart rate increases anywhere from 5 to 25 beats/min. Cutaneous vasodilation FIGURE 1 Physiological changes during a hot flash. Characteristic physiological changes during a hot flash: sensation (SENS), heart rate, internal body temperature (T eso ¼ esophageal), skin temperatures (T for ¼ forehead, T fin ¼ finger), and ambient temperature (T a ¼ ambient). Reproduced from Kronenberg and Downey (7) ã 2008 NRC Canada or its licensors. Reproduced with permission. occurs and blood flow to the skin increases, evident in an increase in finger skin temperature. With the sudden and rapid increase in heat loss (sweating and cutaneous vasodilation), internal body temperature drops. The forehead temperature also cools given the sweating and subsequent evaporative cooling that occurs. These physiological phenomena can be reliably measured in the laboratory (Fig. 2) (7,8). These are laborintensive studies and are not appropriate for clinical trials of various hot flash treatments that involve ambulatory, free living individuals. For this purpose, portable monitors that record changes in sweating, as measured by changes in the electrical conductivity of the skin (skin conductance), are used to correlate subjective reports of hot flash occurrence with this objective physiological change. Mechanisms of hot flashes Estrogen has been studied and used to treat hot flashes for.60 y, but the mechanism by which it works is still in question. This is due to relatively little examination of basic hot flash physiology, which has not received the research attention that has been accorded clinical trials of therapeutic agents. Thus, the body of knowledge on the endocrinology, neurophysiology, thermoregulatory physiology, and other aspects of hot flash biology is limited. One long-standing assumption has been that hot flashes involve transient dysregulation of the thermoregulatory system, triggering homeostatic heat loss mechanisms to return the system to normal. During a hot flash, many of the easily observed physiological changes involve the thermoregulatory and vascular systems. This remains an area of incomplete research. Clearly, estrogen plays some role as a mediator of hot flashes. Hot flashes occur as estrogen levels decline and they are alleviated for the most part by treatment with estrogen (9). Estrogen priming is likely important. Young women with low estrogen levels do not have hot flashes, but if given estrogen and then withdrawn from it, they will have hot flashes. And premenopausal women whose ovaries are removed most often experience hot flashes almost immediately. However, low estrogen levels alone do not explain the presence of hot flashes. Investigators have searched for correlations between estrogen levels and the occurrence of hot flashes in women with and without hot flashes as well as with individual hot flashes with conflicting results. Some population studies have demonstrated inverse relationships between estrogen levels and hot flashes (10,11), as have more recent studies (12). Others, including Freedman et al. (13), have not corroborated these results when small groups of symptomatic and asymptomatic women were compared. There has been examination of the levels of circulating hormones, including sex steroids and gonadotropins, among others. Substances such as luteinizing hormone (14,15), B-endorphin, adrenocorticotropic hormone (16), and others show pulsatile activity that is temporally correlated with hot flash occurrence, but not causally related (7). Freedman et al. (17) have proposed, based on several studies, that elevated brain norepinephrine plays a role in the etiology of hot flashes. Examining the complex interactions of the multiple systems that are involved has not been substantively undertaken. Thus, at this time, there is no definitive determination of what it is that triggers individual hot flashes or explains why some women do or do not experience them. Sociocultural issues in measuring hot flashes Hot flashes occur worldwide, and starting in the 1970s, research documenting such occurrence increased substantially. A wide Hot flashes: physiology and sociocultural perspective 1381S FIGURE 2 Multiple hot flashes: physiological changes. Sensation (SENS), heart rate, finger blood flow, forearm sweating rate, internal body temperature (T eso ¼ esophageal), skin temperatures (T for ¼ forehead, T fin ¼ finger) and ambient temperature (T a ¼ ambient). Adapted from Kronenberg and Downey (7). ã 2008 NRC Canada or its licensors. Reproduced with permission. distribution of the prevalence of hot flashes around the globe continues to be examined, with reports, particularly in Asian countries, of prevalence less than that in the US and other Western countries (1,18). Interest in understanding these differences has raised questions about whether these differences are due to genetic, cultural, environmental, or lifestyle factors such as diet and exercise. Research in Japan has provided particular insight. Japanese women have a high dietary intake of soy (relative to Western countries) and it was hypothesized that this might explain why they have fewer hot flashes than women in the US, Canada, and Europe. Basic science research has established that isoflavones (compounds in soy and other plants) have estrogen-like activity (19). Interest in the relationship between the soy consumption of different populations and hot flash prevalence led to epidemiological studies comparing level of dietary soy intake and frequency of hot flashes in countries such as Japan, where an inverse association between soy intake and hot flashes has been demonstrated (20,21). Clinical studies of soy foods and soy isoflavones to treat hot flashes proliferated, with mixed results, although there was a tendency toward a beneficial effect (22). However, it is now known that there are confounding factors that make this a more complex issue and might contribute to explaining the differing results among the clinical trials. The isoflavone daidzein is biotransformed by intestinal microflora to the active metabolite, equol. The presence of the particular bacterial species responsible for this conversion differs among people in different countries and thus some people are equol producers and some are not (19,23). Further complexity may relate to a critical period for soy consumption relative to its beneficial health effects. This has come to light while trying to understand the observation of lower breast cancer rates in populations with high soy food consumption. Exposure during adulthood did not support these observations. Data are accumulating to support a protective effect of soy when it is consumed during early life (childhood/ adolescence) with regard to breast cancer later in life (24). Soy foods are a staple in Asian cuisine and are consumed throughout life, suggesting their role in breast cancer prevention. Consumption of soy or genistein affects gene expression and activates estrogen receptor a, thereby affecting BRCA1 (25,26). Similarly, it is possible that consuming soy during puberty may affect whether one experiences hot flashes during menopause; initiating soy consumption or isoflavone supplementation at age 50 y may not have the same outcome of reducing hot flashes. The Japanese experience In the 1980s, Lock et al. (27) studied menopause among Japanese women and asked women about symptoms, including those typically experienced by American and Canadian women; they also asked the Japanese women (and their physicians) how they would describe this time of life and the symptoms they experienced. The respondents used a combination of 3 terms (sudden feeling of heat; feeling hot or flushed; rush of blood to the head) to encompass what Western women and physicians mean by the single term hot flash. The Japanese women reported fewer hot flashes than their Western counterparts. The researchers concluded that fewer Japanese women were experiencing hot flashes and night sweats. 1382S Supplement TABLE 1 Symptoms recalled in previous 2-wk period in Japanese women: comparison across 20 y 1 Romanized Japanese symptom English symptom Lock, n = 1141 Melby, n = 140 Incidence % Katakori Shoulder stiffness Zutsuu Headache Youtsuu Lumbago Benpi Constipation Hieshou Chilliness Iraira Irritability Fumin Insomnia Kansetsutsuu Aches and pains in the joints Kaze o yoku hiku Frequent colds Kyuu na nekkan nobose, hoteri Any hot flash Ki ga meiru Depression Memai Dizziness Kyuu na hakkan Sudden perspiration Ne ase Night sweats Adapted from Melby 2005 (28) and Lock et al. (27). Reprinted by permission of Elsevier. Twenty years later, Melby (28) conducted a follow-up study in Japan, this time focusing on the more linguistically nuanced terminologies as she came to understand how Japanese women spoke about their sensations of heat and sweating during the menopausal years. Melby included Lock s symptom list in her questionnaire but asked about hot flash terms separately, and found there was an increase in symptom reporting in the time since Lock s study. There was an increase in those reporting each of the symptoms comprising the nuanced components hot flashes (Table 1) (28). Some of the explanation for increased symptom reporting may involve the globalization of the Western approach to and discussion of menopause. Zeserson (29) commented on the media s impact on how women discuss and view their symptoms. In the case of hot flashes, Zeserson (29) noted that Japanese women began using the Americanized expression hotto furasshu and became conversant with the Western terminology of hot flash, having heard this in the media. As described earlier, there are a number of measurable physiological changes that constitute a hot flash. Some women s heart rate increases, some women sweat, while others flush and feel a sensation of heat. In Western countries, women describe whether they flush or sweat during a hot flash; they name this constellation of changes as a hot flash or hot flush. Japanese women describe an individual component of hot flash sensation if they experience it. In Traditional Chinese medicine (and its Kampo counterpart in Japan), a practitioner would identify the particular characteristics of an individual woman presenting with the Western diagnosis of hot flashes, whether she sweats (sweat effusion or fa han has many different presentations), flushes (mian jia chao hong, e.g., characterizes a visible malar flush while fa re represents a generalized sensation of heat), or has rapid heart rate (jing ji or palpitations) [(30); K.V. Ergil, personal communication], and the diagnostic process would lead to treatment related to that pattern of symptom presentation. Thus, not all women with a Western diagnosis of menopausal hot flashes would receive the same suggested treatment. Western investigators, too, can apply these distinctions and stratify clinical trials to explore whether some treatments are more appropriate for certain subsets of women with specific patterns of symptoms. Interestingly, Melby (31) administered to both men and women in Japan the same symptom questionnaire. Both groups reported shoulder stiffness (the most prevalent symptom reported by women) and men reported more night sweats than did the women (Table 2) (31). How do we determine which symptoms are influenced by cultural factors and expectations and which are a function of hormonal or other physiological change? Do women of Japanese ancestry really have fewer hot flashes than western women or do they just not report them? Theories have been offered to explain the differences in hot flash prevalence around the world, including genetics, physiology, expectation, lifestyle (soy foods, exercise), or other environmental factors. Brown et al. (32) looked elsewhere to examine whether part of the explanation for fewer hot flashes among Japanese-American women might involve a lack of reporting rather than a lack of occurrence of hot flashes. Their study, conducted in Hawaii, compared objectively measured hot TABLE 2 Romanized Japanese symptom Two-week symptom prevalence in Japanese women and men 1 English symptom Females, n =32 Males, n =22 x 22 % Katakori Shoulder stiffness Sutoresu Stress Kyuu na hakkan Sudden perspiration Iraira Irritability Ne ase Night sweats Shinkei no shinchou Nervous tension Kentaikan Exhaustion Adapted from Melby 2006 (31). Reprinted by permission of Taylor and Francis Group, 2 The nonparametric chi-square test was used to assess sex difference in symptoms experienced in the previous 2 wk and reported by.9% of the sample. 3 Significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed). 4 Significant at the 0.10 level (2-tailed). Hot flashes: physiology and sociocultural perspective 1383S flashes (using the measure of skin conductance) with self-report in women of Japanese descent and European descent living in Hilo, Hawaii. They administered a postal questionnaire asking about symptoms experienced in the past 2 wk and
Recommended
View more...
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks
SAVE OUR EARTH

We need your sign to support Project to invent "SMART AND CONTROLLABLE REFLECTIVE BALLOONS" to cover the Sun and Save Our Earth.

More details...

Sign Now!

We are very appreciated for your Prompt Action!

x