08_Galian vs. State Assurance Company, Ltd..pdf

Please download to get full document.

View again

of 2
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Information Report
Category:

Documents

Published:

Views: 32 | Pages: 2

Extension: PDF | Download: 0

Share
Related documents
Description
Galian vs. State Assurance Company, Ltd. February 10, 1915| Trent, J. | Opinion Rule PETITIONER: Francisco Galian RESPONDENT: State Assurance Company, Ltd. SUMMARY: Galian claimed proceeds from an open fire insurance policy. The insurance company wanted to give him a lower amount. In determining the amount to be given, the insurance company used the testimonies of three experts. SC declared tha
Transcript
  ! #$ % '() *+ +, -((./ %0, 1234 %56 7+8) ! #$%&$' )*+ ),)-. /$ 01+  !  . 2340450 6%7 9:;<;<=>:? 8 !$&094:95 ;&74&0 ?:*9=>@:>;A <1&1 =::%$&09 >5?3&0'+ @1AB *BCC-?DA  ;&74&0 97&4? A 3$59 A: C$5? &0 53 0 C4$ 40:%$&09 35749'B /D 40:%$&09 95?3&0' E&01 A 15 F4G D4? & 75E $ &?5%01B H0 A 1 $?4040F 1D &?5%01 15 # F4G 0+ 1D 40:%$&09 95?3&0' %: A 1D 1 :14?504 : 5C 1D$ I3 $1:B <> A 97&$ A 1D&1 1D 1 :14?504 : 5C 1D I3 $1: E $ :%3 $C494&7+ &0A 1D $ E&: 05 0 A C5$ I3 $1 E410 :: : &0'?5$ &: 1D &$1497 : 74:1 A E $ 05$?&77' %: A #' 3 537 C5$ 1D 4$ 5E0 950G 04 09 + &0A 1D 3$49 : &$ $ &A47' &G&47&#7 40 $ 1&47 :15$ :B @=1;?<>:A  < 91450 J, 5C 6%7 )K* 3$5G4A : 1D&1 I3 $1 E410 :: : ?&' # &A?411 A 50 ?&11 $: $ L%4$40F :3 94&7 M05E7 AF B H0 1D4: 9&: + 05 :3 94&7 M05E7 AF E&: 0 A A # 9&%: 1D 3$49 : 5C &$1497 : :5%FD1 15 # &33$4: A 9&0 # : 0 40 $ 1&47 :15$ :+ &0A 41 4: ?5:1 3$5#&#7 1D&1 ;&74&0 D4?: 7C #5%FD1 1D ? C5$ D4: 5E0 950G 04 09 &0A 95?C5$1B /D%:+ ;&74&0 4: M05E7 AF &#7 &#5%1 1D 3$49 : 5C :&4A 41 ?:B E-1;*A )B N&0%&$' O-+ ),)O8 /D 3$53 $1' E&: 40:%$ A C5$ PK+***B OB Q&' O-+ ),)8 /D A&' C5775E40F 1D C4$ + 1D 40:%$ A 3$ : 01 A &0 41 ?4R A :1&1 ? 01 5C 1D F55A: 9501&40 A 40 1D D5%: &1 1D 14? 5C 1D C4$ + 1D 151&7 G&7% 5C ED49D D 97&4?: 15 # PJ+-)OB /D 40:%$ A 3$53 $1' E&: 051 151&77' A :1$5' A+ :5 1D 40:%$ A 97&4? A 507' PO+,),BSJB KB /D 40:%$&09 95?3&0' 401 $35: A 1D A C 0: 1D&1 1D 35749' D&A # 0 C5$C 41 A # 9&%: ;&74&0 3$ : 01 A C&7: 97&4?: T 1D&1 1D $ E&: &0 &77 F A 151&7 75::+ 1D&1 051 &77 1D &$1497 : 74:1 A 40 1D 97&4? 5C 75:: E $ 40 1D D5%: ED $ &0A ED 0 1D C4$ 599%$$ A+ &0A 1D&1 1D&1 D &11$4#%1 A F$ &1 $ G&7% 15 1D &$1497 : 1D&0 1D ' E $ E5$1DB JB U350 1$4&7+ 1D $ E&: G4A 09 C5$ ;&74&0 1D&1 1D :1&1 ? 01 3$ : 01 A &C1 $ 1D C4$ E&: :%#:1&014&77' 95$$ 91+ #51D 40 L%&01414 : &0A G&7% :B V 1 :14C4 A 1D&1 D + E41D 1D &::4:1&09 5C D4: #$51D $+ 4?? A4&1 7' 3$ 3&$ A 1D :1&1 ? 01 C$5? ? ?5$' 4?? A4&1 7' &C1 $ 1D C4$ B -B /D 95?3&0' 3$ : 01 A K E410 :: : ED5 E $ &1 1D :9 0 5C 1D C4$ :D5$17' &C1 $ 41 599%$$ AB !$5? 1D 3D515F$&3D: :%#?411 A+ 41 &33 &$: 1D&1 1D C4$:1 C755$ 5C ;&74&0W: $ :4A 01 E&: 051 A&?&F A #' 1D C4$ &1 &77+ #%1 A4A :%CC $ A&?&F C$5? E&1 $ &0A #$ &M&F B /D $&11&0 E5$M 50 1D 9D&4$:+ 40 1D : 950A C755$+ E&: 014$ 7' 950:%? AB /D E55AE5$M E&: 3$5#&#7' 507' 9D&$$ A 5$ :95$9D AB /D C4$ A4A 1D ?5:1 A&?&F 40 1D # A$55?+ ED $ 1D $55C 3&$17' C 77 40B X Q$B Y5%0F 1 :14C4 A 1D&1 D I&?40 A 1D 9501 01: 5C 1D D5%: &0A :14?&1 A 1D 75:: &1 P)+***+ #%1 1D4: E&: 507' & 9&:%&7 :14?&1 B X Q$B Z5E 1 :14C4 A 1D&1 D ?&A & $5%FD :14?&1 + 1D&1 1D&1 1D :14?&1 A G&7% 5C 1D F55A: 40 1D C4$:1 C755$ E&: P-**+ &0A C$5? 1D %33 $ C755$+ P)+-**B X Q$B @&40F+ &F 01 5C 1D 40:%$&09 95?3&0'+ :14?&1 A 1D 75:: &1 P)+-**B V 1 :14C4 A 1D&1 051D40F D&A # 0 014$ 7' 950:%? A #' 1D C4$ B [B /> $ C%: A 15 950:4A $ 1D 1 :14?504 : 5C ;&74&0 &0A D4: #$51D $ &: 15 1D G&7% 5C 1D 3$53 $1' 50 1D F$5%0A 1D&1 0 41D $ E&: L%&74C4 A 15 &33$&4: 1D 3$53 $1'B /D 95%$1 A 1 $?40 A 1D&1 1D 3$53 $1' E&: E5$1D P)+*** &1 1D 14? 5C 1D C4$ B <**B: 8 \]^ 1D 1$4&7 95%$1 95$$ 917' A 1 $?40 A 1D G&7% 5C 1D 3$53 $1' _ ^2B F:7@ 8 ;&74&0 4: 01417 A 15 1D :%? 5C PO+,),B,OB ?-;<=A )B /D $ 4: 05 :&14:C&915$' 3$55C 1D&1 ;&74&0 4097%A A 40 D4: 41 ?4R A 74:1 &0' 3$53 $1' ED49D E&: 051 1D $ B V 3$ 3&$ A 1D 74:1 C$5? ? ?5$'+ &0A &#:57%1 &99%$&9' 95%7A D&$A7' # I3 91 AB OB /D 40:%$&09 95?3&0'W: 95%0: 7 E&: 95$$ 91 40 5#: $G40F 1D&1 1D ;&74&0W: 40G 015$' 5C D4: &0A D4: E4C W: E&$A$5# 4: 155 I1$&G&F&01 + 950:4A $40F 1D&1 ;&74&0 4: 507' & 9&:D4 $ 5C & 759&7 #%:40 :: D5%: E41D & :&7&$' 5C P)S- 3 $ ?501DB H1 &7:5 &33 &$: 1D&1 1D I1$&5$A40&$' 74:1 5C E &$40F &33&$ 7 E&: :%#?411 A 15 1D 40:%$&09 95?3&0' # C5$ &0' 5C 1D 1D$ I3 $1: ?&A D4: I&?40&1450 50 1D 3$53 $1'B KB /D >5%$1 A 9740 A 15 &99 31 1D 1 :14?504 : 5C 1D 1D$ E410 :: : C5$ 1D 40:%$&09 95?3&0'B X ` 9&%: 41 &33 &$: 1D&1 :5? 5C 1D 37&4014CCW: 3$53 $1' E&: 014$ 7' 950:%? A #' 1D C4$ &0A :5? E&: #&A7' A&?&F A 1D&1 41 E&: 4?35::4#7 15 a%AF 5C 41: G&7% B X /D 40:3 91450 ?&A #' 1D : : G $&7 E410 :: : E&: :5 (.4,/G$0$ #6 40 G4 E 5C 1D 4$ 5335$1%041'+ 1D&1 1D 4$ 95097%:450: A5 051 9&$$' 950G491450B JB /D >5%$1 &7:5 A 9740 A 15 &F$ E41D 1D 1$4&7 95%$1W: C40A40F 1D&1 ;&74&0 &0A D4: #$51D $ E $ 051 L%&74C4 A 15 &33$&4: 1D G&7% 5C 1D 3$53 $1'B /D 41 ?4R A &$1497 : &$ 50 :&7 40 $ 1&47 :D53: G $'ED $ &0A 1D 3$49 : &$ $ &A47' &G&47&#7 15 &0'50 : M40F 1D 40C5$?&1450B  Q5$ 5G $+ 1D : &$ 1D40F: 1D&1 3 537 E41D $ &:50&#7' C&4$ 4095? 3%$9D&: C5$ 1D 4$ 5E0 950G 04 09 &0A 95?C5$1B V 09 + 40C5$?&1450 &: 15 1D 4$ G&7% ?%:1 0 9 ::&$47' # &9L%4$ A #' &77 :%9D 40A4G4A%&7:B /D $ C5$ + 1D $ E&: 05 0 A C5$ &0 I3 $1 E410 ::B -B ;&74&0 E&: 4014?&1 7' &9L%&401 A E41D 1D &$1497 : A :9$4# A #' D4?B V + 05 A5%#1+ 3%$9D&: A ?5:1 5C 1D ?B [B /D 3$53 $1' E&: E5$1D PJ+-)OB /D :&7G&F &?5%01 A 15 P)O*BJ*B /D4: 7 &G : & 3&$14&7 75:: &?5%0140F 15 PJ+K,)B[*B =: 1D 3$53 $1' E&: 40:%$ A C5$ 507' PK+***+ 1D 40:%$ $ ?%:1 # &$ & 35$1450 5C 1D 75:: $ 3$ : 01 A #' & C$&91450 1D 0%? $&15$ 5C ED49D 4: 1D &?5%01 5C 1D 40:%$&09 &0A 1D A 05?40&15$ 5C ED49D 4: 1D G&7% 5C 1D 3$53 $1' &1 1D 14? 5C 1D C4$ B /D4: 01417 : 1D 40:%$ A 15 & a%AF? 01 &F&40:1 1D 40:%$ $ C5$ O+,),B,OB *:9-?-;: =9<><=> ! #$%&'() H) )B /D 40:%$&09 35749' 4: 97 &$ 1D&1 1D 95?3&0' &F$ A 15 3&' ;&74&0 &0 &?5%01 051 I9 A40F PK+***B >7&%: )S 5C 1D 35749'+ D5E G $+ :1&1 : 1D&1 4C 1D 151&7 &?5%01 5C 1D A&?&F : I9 A: PK+***+ 1D I9 :: E477 # #5$0 #' 1D 40:%$ AB OB N%:149 Q5$ 7&0A C40A: 1D&1+ G 0 1D5%FD 1D $ 4: 05 9&1 F5$49&7 3$505%09 ? 01 ' 1 &: 15 1D G&74A41' 5C :%9D 97&%: + :%9D 97&%: 4: G457&14G 5C 1D C&4$ 401 01 5C 1D &F$ ? 01+ &0A 9&0 0&1%$&77' A 9 4G 1D 40:%$ A 40 1D ?&a5$41' 5C 9&: :B  + ,'- ') H6 A4:: 0140FB b^5 I37&0&1450c
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks